English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A.C.

Dícese de los políglotas o practicantes de lenguas varias.

Moderador: Larús

Avatar de Usuario
Nieves
Foroadicto
Mensajes: 4937
Registrado: 26 Nov 2008 18:38

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por Nieves »

LauraCo escribió:I'm reading the forth chapter and everything goes around the husband, but it's what you say it's too easy if it's the husband. We will see :D
Well it's also possible that the easiest solution is correct, Poirot says :meditando: :lol:
1
Avatar de Usuario
Carmen Neke
Foroadicto
Mensajes: 3142
Registrado: 26 Oct 2008 20:24
Contactar:

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por Carmen Neke »

A pity there is no butler at Styles :mrgreen: Only Dorcas, and she seems to be very respectable and devoted to her mistress. But then you never know, human nature being what it is (as Miss Marple would say).
1
Avatar de Usuario
gaditana
No puedo vivir sin este foro
Mensajes: 543
Registrado: 30 Jul 2008 20:32
Ubicación: cádiz

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por gaditana »

I´ve read the first chapter. I don´t like Alfred!
1
Avatar de Usuario
gaditana
No puedo vivir sin este foro
Mensajes: 543
Registrado: 30 Jul 2008 20:32
Ubicación: cádiz

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por gaditana »

I´ve finished the third chapter. The storie starts to be interesting!
The mother has been murdered
! At the moment, it´s easy read the book in English for me.
1
Avatar de Usuario
LauraCo
No tengo vida social
Mensajes: 1097
Registrado: 04 Ago 2010 12:48
Ubicación: Barcelona

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por LauraCo »

gaditana escribió:I´ve read the first chapter. I don´t like Alfred!
Me neither. But it makes you feel that he's guilty when the most probable (in my opinion)
it's that he won't be the murderer
. Like Nieves said, the easiest solution is likely to be correct; but I hope that everything will turn into something more complicated :mrgreen:
The character I like most is Poirot :mrgreen: I like the way he acts; he never show his emotions, he just only analyze and try to relate everything.
Leyendo :101: :
Les calces al sol - Regina Rodríguez Sirvent
Ciudad Feliz - Charles Montgomery
Avatar de Usuario
DarkLady Juliet
Vivo aquí
Mensajes: 5542
Registrado: 06 Sep 2010 00:25
Ubicación: En Darkilandia, en los libros y en Madrid también.

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por DarkLady Juliet »

How are you finding the writing? Are sentences too long? Words too difficult? Easy to follow? Do you think her language is direct or does she convey mystery through twisted expressions?

OT
Dear friends, I'm a little bit out of here lately, I began in a new job all of a sudden and some other circumstances are shortening my time a lot... I hope to get back to routine soon.
Avatar de Usuario
LauraCo
No tengo vida social
Mensajes: 1097
Registrado: 04 Ago 2010 12:48
Ubicación: Barcelona

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por LauraCo »

I read til chapter 5 and 6 and I've found it very interesting :D
the topic of the last will destroyed; the fact that they've discovered the body has been poisoned with strychnine; the inquest, and the difficulty to not guilt Mr. Inglethorp althought he makes it difficult to answer right and telling "the truth" . But I'm still thinking that he's not guilty :lol:
I've got a question related to the way of writing, in chapter 6 at the beginning the main character goes to a farm and speak to someone, but this guy speaks very odd, like:

"You'm from the Hall, bain't you?"

[...] "More'n once too." (I suppose that here it could be than)

What does it mean?
Leyendo :101: :
Les calces al sol - Regina Rodríguez Sirvent
Ciudad Feliz - Charles Montgomery
Avatar de Usuario
Carmen Neke
Foroadicto
Mensajes: 3142
Registrado: 26 Oct 2008 20:24
Contactar:

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por Carmen Neke »

Agatha Christie is imitating the strange way peasants speak English and their creative use of the grammar :twisted: :twisted: English peasants are not much better in their ways of speaking than Spanish ones!! :lol: "You'm from the Hall, bain't you?" shoud be "You're from the Hall, aren't you?"

I found this scene very funny, with poor captain Hastings trying to figure out what this man "who leered at him cunningly" was saying :lol: :lol: :lol:
1
Avatar de Usuario
LauraCo
No tengo vida social
Mensajes: 1097
Registrado: 04 Ago 2010 12:48
Ubicación: Barcelona

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por LauraCo »

Carmen Neke escribió:Agatha Christie is imitating the strange way peasants speak English and their creative use of the grammar :twisted: :twisted: English peasants are not much better in their ways of speaking than Spanish ones!! :lol: "You'm from the Hall, bain't you?" shoud be "You're from the Hall, aren't you?"

I found this scene very funny, with poor captain Hastings trying to figure out what this man "who leered at him cunningly" was saying :lol: :lol: :lol:
Thank you Carmen :60: :60:
Leyendo :101: :
Les calces al sol - Regina Rodríguez Sirvent
Ciudad Feliz - Charles Montgomery
Avatar de Usuario
Nieves
Foroadicto
Mensajes: 4937
Registrado: 26 Nov 2008 18:38

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por Nieves »

I finished reading it.
At the end of Chapter 12 I laughed a lot, not because there was something funny, but by the words:
"Messieurs, mesdames, let me introduces you, the murderer, Mr. Alfred Iglethorpe"
jajajaja. The truth is that I had completely dismissed
Mr. Iglethorpe.
Mrs. Christie got sidetrack because neither contemplated the possibility that
Miss Howard was the mastermind of the plan. :D
DarkLady Juliet escribió:How are you finding the writing? Are sentences too long? Words too difficult? Easy to follow? Do you think her language is direct or does she convey mystery through twisted expressions?
I've had no problem in continuing to read even the aforementioned parties for Laura and Carmen.
1
Avatar de Usuario
Dulce001
Lector voraz
Mensajes: 170
Registrado: 25 Dic 2010 21:13

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por Dulce001 »

I,m sorry but I didn´t have enough time to read :(
1
Avatar de Usuario
DarkLady Juliet
Vivo aquí
Mensajes: 5542
Registrado: 06 Sep 2010 00:25
Ubicación: En Darkilandia, en los libros y en Madrid también.

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por DarkLady Juliet »

Don't worry Dulce, if you finally find the time, you can write your comments here, if you rather join May MC, (I don't remember right now if it's Mitch Albom's...) we'll be glad to see you there too.
Avatar de Usuario
Tangerine
Lector
Mensajes: 96
Registrado: 20 Ago 2006 13:24
Ubicación: Barcelona
Contactar:

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por Tangerine »

I couldn't make it for this MC either :( I hope I will be able to attend the one in May, although I find it quite tough because my maternity leave will be over and I will have to get back to work and I also have exams in May. As soon as we have the title decided I will try to find it in paper format, and if I can, I will join the MC. I find it difficult to read in digital format because I don't have an e-reader...

Cheers!
1
Avatar de Usuario
DarkLady Juliet
Vivo aquí
Mensajes: 5542
Registrado: 06 Sep 2010 00:25
Ubicación: En Darkilandia, en los libros y en Madrid también.

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por DarkLady Juliet »

Tangerine, it is already decided. I'll write a post with the three following MCs in English. Nevertheless, we can propose more, make more MCs and join as many as we want.

Have a nice Day of the Book!
:60:
Avatar de Usuario
LauraCo
No tengo vida social
Mensajes: 1097
Registrado: 04 Ago 2010 12:48
Ubicación: Barcelona

Re: English MC - April - The Mysterious Affair at Styles - A

Mensaje por LauraCo »

I've already finished the book, and I've enjoyed it very much!
To be the first book of Agatha C. read I like it very much: the plot, the characters, how to link things, to know the guilty... Above all, I like Poirot's character :mrgreen:

But the most surprising it is the end
it was Mr Inglethorp the guilty! I couldn't belive it, at last it's what Nieves said before that the easiest solution is the correct one :cunao:
Leyendo :101: :
Les calces al sol - Regina Rodríguez Sirvent
Ciudad Feliz - Charles Montgomery
Responder